Smart TVs Kept Sending Tracking-Related Data After Users Opted Out, Study Finds
Lab tests show the viewing-data switch did not silence the two brands' sets, but encrypted traffic cannot reveal what was inside it.
Northeastern University researchers found that a Vizio TV and a Samsung TV kept sending traffic consistent with content tracking after owners opted out. The findings stop short of proving data was collected or sold, and other TVs honored the opt-out. Settings and workarounds can reduce collection, but none removes it entirely.
In lab tests by Northeastern University researchers, a Vizio TV and Samsung TVs kept sending network traffic consistent with automatic content recognition (ACR) after the viewing-data setting was switched off. Four other operating systems, covering LG, Sony, Amazon Fire TV and VIDAA sets, fully suppressed that traffic when the owner opted out. The result drew wide coverage in late October and early November 2026, including a Malwarebytes report that put it in the headline as TVs that "seem to ignore" opt-outs.
The practical question is whether flipping the switch does what the menu promises. The evidence so far says the switch is unreliable on at least some sets, but it does not show what the continuing traffic contains, and no court or regulator has found that either company ignored an opt-out. The details matter, because the strongest headline version of the story claims more than the researchers observed.
What ACR is and what an opt-out is supposed to stop
Automatic content recognition works by sampling what appears on the screen or comes through the speakers and matching it against a reference library. That lets a manufacturer or its partners infer which programs, ads or channels a household watches, whatever the source: a cable box, an antenna, a game console or the TV's own apps. Coverage of the Texas lawsuits describes screenshots taken as often as every 500 milliseconds, but that cadence is an allegation in those suits, not a measured finding.
The opt-out is the on-device toggle that is meant to turn this off. Brands label it differently: Samsung calls it Viewing Information Services, Vizio calls it Viewing Data, LG uses Live Plus, Sony uses Samba Interactive TV and Roku uses Use Info from TV Inputs, according to two how-to guides from smarttvs.org and SecurityOnline. Those guides are low-authority sources, and the names should be checked against each manufacturer's support pages.
The researchers behind the study also argue that the naming is part of the problem. According to a secondary summary of the paper, five of the eight operating systems avoid the phrase "Automatic Content Recognition" in their menus, and the authors link this to a known dark-pattern category, meaning interface design that steers people away from informed choices. That finding comes from a single secondary source and has not been checked against the paper.
How the Northeastern study tested the opt-out
The study, titled "Watching the Watchers: Privacy Analysis of U.S. Smart TV Automatic Content Recognition," is described on its project website. Researchers tested twelve smart TVs from ten manufacturers in 5,943 experiments. The sets run the eight operating systems behind roughly 95% of US smart TVs, a share that is the researchers' own estimate. Peer-review status and publication venue were not confirmed, so the work should be treated as a published research project rather than a vetted journal article.
The design is straightforward. Each scenario ran 30 times with ACR enabled and 30 times after opting out in the TV's settings, in random order so one test would not contaminate the next. A testbed played identical content on every TV with no one touching the remote, and recorded all network traffic. A scenario counted as "tracked" if the ACR endpoint received traffic correlated with the content in 80% or more of the 30 runs.
What "consistent with ACR" means
The study's key term is "traffic consistent with ACR." It refers to data sent to a server whose volume rises and falls with what is on screen. That is an inference from traffic patterns, not a look inside the data. Samsung and Vizio traffic is encrypted, so the researchers could see where it went, when and how much, but not what it said.
The opt-out worked fully on LG's webOS, Google TV on Sony sets, VIDAA OS and Fire TV OS, according to the project site. That is the four-of-eight tally Malwarebytes cites, and it counts operating systems, not individual TVs. The remaining results are mixed, and the two most discussed are Vizio and Samsung.
What the tests found on Vizio and Samsung sets
Vizio: traffic in every opted-out scenario
On the Vizio SmartCast set, an endpoint hosted on Amazon Kinesis kept receiving content-correlated traffic in 100% of opted-out scenarios, according to coverage of the study. TechSpot and Yahoo Tech both report that the traffic continued even while the TV sat idle on its home screen, and Yahoo Tech adds that the set sent as much data to that server after opt-out as before.
Only one Vizio set appears to have been tested, so other models or firmware versions may behave differently. The result is also a snapshot, since a software update can change what a TV does. The researchers themselves stop short of saying Vizio broke its 2017 settlement with the Federal Trade Commission.
Samsung: a result that depends on what is on screen
Samsung's picture is less uniform. Slashdot, summarizing Techdirt, quotes the paper's abstract as saying ACR-consistent traffic persisted in more than 60% of the evaluated scenarios. The per-scenario counts, as reported by Cybersecuritynews and CyberInsider rather than the paper itself, vary widely.
| Scenario | Runs showing traffic | Total runs |
|---|---|---|
| Samsung's own streaming service | 30 | 30 |
| Antenna (moving video) | 41 | 60 |
| HDMI | 18 | 30 |
| Tubi | 6 | 30 |
Traffic appeared in every opted-out run of Samsung's built-in streaming service and in a smaller share of runs on other sources. One summary of the paper says Samsung's opt-out was more likely to work during antenna broadcasts, yet the counts above show traffic in 41 of 60 antenna runs, a share no lower than the 18 of 30 on HDMI. The discrepancy suggests the second-hand figures need checking against the paper before anyone leans on them.
The other brands and sources
Roku's opt-out does not cover Roku's own streaming service. For antenna viewing it worked on a Roku TV, while on a TCL set, which also runs Roku's operating system, traffic continued in 9 of 90 runs. According to CyberInsider's summary, all seven ACR-enabled platforms produced content-correlated traffic during antenna viewing and five did during HDMI playback, while none met the study's threshold for Netflix or YouTube.
Slashdot's summary says no vendor tracks Netflix viewing, reportedly out of concern about violating agreements with Netflix. That reason is not established. The seven and five platform counts also come from a single secondary source.
A separate Vizio issue: WatchFree+
Coverage also describes a distinct problem with Vizio's WatchFree+ channels. Program or channel names were reportedly exposed through unencrypted DNS lookups and the server-name field of encrypted connections, both tied to the streaming provider Amagi. That would let anyone observing the home network reconstruct what was watched, regardless of the ACR setting. TechSpot says a working opt-out would not help there and that no setting turns WatchFree+ off, but neither claim has been checked against the paper.
What the traffic proves, and what the companies say
Continued traffic is a sign of something, not proof that viewing data is still being collected, stored or monetized. Because the payloads are encrypted, the traffic alone cannot rule out an innocent explanation. Careful coverage therefore describes a potentially ineffective opt-out rather than proven continued collection.
Vizio offers one such explanation. According to a Spanish-language Infobae summary of reporting by The Verge, the company said the encrypted traffic is routine operating data and not ACR. This is a single second-hand report; no first-hand Vizio statement was located. The researchers counter that the endpoint's traffic is correlated with on-screen content, which is what distinguishes it from generic housekeeping, though the traffic alone does not settle the matter.
Samsung told the site HDTVTest:
When a customer disables ACR, viewing information is not collected or transmitted.
That statement conflicts with the traffic observations on its face, but HDTVTest framed it as a response to a different set of claims, made by a user known as @log4j. It is not confirmed to be a reply to the Northeastern paper, so the two should not be read as a direct exchange. Infobae separately reports that Samsung answered The Verge's questions while Vizio did not answer those about microphones and screenshots, again from a single report.
The legal backdrop: a 2017 settlement and Texas lawsuits
Expectations for Vizio were set in 2017. The Federal Trade Commission announced that Vizio would pay $2.2 million to the agency and the State of New Jersey to settle charges that it collected viewing histories from 11 million smart TVs without consent. The order required deletion of most of the data collected and a privacy program, in addition to the payment. Courthouse News reported the split as $1.5 million to the FTC and $1 million to New Jersey, with $300,000 of the New Jersey portion suspended.
According to the FTC's complaint, as summarized by deceptive.design, the TVs had since February 2014 been designed to track viewing continuously through ACR software that was on by default. Sources differ on the order's consent language: legal summaries describe a requirement for affirmative express consent, meaning a prominent disclosure and consent before collection, while Malwarebytes describes it as requiring an opt-out. The order's text would settle the point, and whether Vizio's current behavior is compatible with it is a legal question the research does not answer.
The newer actions center on Texas. On December 15, 2025, Attorney General Ken Paxton sued Samsung, LG, Sony, Hisense and TCL under the state's deceptive trade practices law, The Record reported. Vizio was not among the five defendants. The filings allege, among other things, that ACR can capture data while a TV is offline and send it once reconnected, a claim that has not been independently verified.
Malwarebytes reported in March 2026 that Samsung agreed in a settlement to stop collecting ACR data from Texans without explicit, informed consent and to rewrite its on-screen privacy prompts. Samsung also faces a federal class action in New York alleging that its TVs track and sell viewing data without informed consent, in violation of the Video Privacy Protection Act and state laws. That case is an allegation only. The Texas action targeted consent and disclosure rather than the opt-out toggle itself, and primary Texas documents were not reviewed.
Which settings actually limit collection
The first step is still the manufacturer's toggle, even with its limits, since it did work on several platforms in the study. Menu paths vary by model year and firmware, so searching the TV's settings for the names below is more reliable than following a fixed path. The paths listed here come from secondary how-to guides rather than manufacturer support pages.
- Samsung: guides point to Settings, then Support, then Terms & Privacy, then Privacy Choices, where Viewing Information Services can be turned off. They also suggest disabling Interest-Based Advertising and Voice Recognition Services.
- Vizio: guides point to Menu, then System, then Reset & Admin, where Viewing Data can be turned off. One low-authority site, smarttvs.org, advises turning off Personalized Ads too, because ad targeting may still function if that toggle stays on.
- Other brands: LG's setting is Live Plus, Sony's is Samba Interactive TV and Roku's is Use Info from TV Inputs.
The toggle is necessary but not sufficient. Consumer Reports has said that even with ACR off, a smart TV keeps collecting information for its manufacturer, possibly including location and which apps are opened. That guidance is undated in the retrieved copy and appears to be about five years old, so current advice from the organization should be checked. Its recommendation to reset a TV and decline viewing-data collection during setup traces to an NBC News report on a 2018 Consumer Reports investigation.
Stronger measures, with tradeoffs
Given the study's findings, researchers and press coverage point to three stronger options: disconnecting the TV from Wi-Fi or Ethernet and watching through a streaming stick, blocking identified ACR endpoints on the home network, or using the blocklist the researchers shared. None has been tested by independent parties, and each carries a cost, since a disconnected TV loses its smart features.
Each also has caveats. Network-level blocking of known ACR servers reduced exposure but did not stop the WatchFree+ DNS leakage. External streaming devices have their own tracking: the study found Fire TV's opt-out suppressed ACR traffic, but those devices' other data collection was not examined. Whether disconnecting a TV prevents queued data from being sent later, as the Texas complaint alleges, remains unverified.
What it means, and what to watch
The study's clearest contribution is a contrast: the same switch fully worked on some platforms and did not on others, under identical test conditions. That undercuts any argument that an opt-out cannot be made to work, and it shows that a menu label is not evidence of behavior. For owners of the tested Vizio and Samsung models, the traffic result is a reason for caution, not a verdict about what happened to their data.
Several things will decide how much weight the finding carries. Publication of the full paper and its review status, direct responses from Samsung and Vizio, and any test of newer firmware would all sharpen the picture. So would the outcome of the Texas and New York cases and any clarification of what the FTC's 2017 order requires. Until then, the settings help, the strongest protection is keeping the TV off the network, and the contents of the traffic remain unknown.
Frequently asked questions
Do Vizio and Samsung TVs ignore tracking opt-outs?
In Northeastern University's tests, a Vizio set sent ACR-consistent traffic in 100% of opted-out scenarios, and Samsung sets did so in many scenarios, with more than 60% overall according to the paper's abstract as quoted by Slashdot. The traffic is encrypted, so the study shows that data kept flowing to a content-correlated server, not what the data contained. Vizio has said, via second-hand reporting, that it is routine operating data.
What is ACR on a smart TV?
Automatic content recognition is software that identifies what is on the screen by fingerprinting video or audio. It lets a manufacturer or its partners infer what a household watches from any source, including antenna, HDMI devices and apps. Menus often label it with other names, such as Viewing Information Services on Samsung and Viewing Data on Vizio.
Which smart TVs honored the opt-out in the study?
According to the project site, the opt-out fully suppressed ACR-consistent traffic on LG's webOS, Google TV on Sony, VIDAA OS and Fire TV OS. Roku's opt-out did not cover Roku's own streaming service, though it worked for antenna viewing on a Roku TV. Traffic continued on a TCL set in 9 of 90 antenna runs.
Does turning off ACR stop all data collection by a smart TV?
No. Consumer Reports has said that a smart TV can keep collecting information for its manufacturer even with ACR off, possibly including location and which apps are opened. That guidance is several years old. Vizio's WatchFree+ channels were also reported to expose program names through DNS lookups regardless of the ACR setting.
Has Vizio or Samsung been found to violate an opt-out?
No court or regulator has made such a finding. Vizio settled FTC and New Jersey charges in 2017 over collecting viewing data without consent, and the study's researchers do not say it broke that settlement. Texas sued Samsung and four other makers, not Vizio, and Samsung reportedly settled; those claims concern consent and disclosure, and the New York class action against Samsung is an allegation.
Sources (18)
- Watching the Watchers: Privacy Analysis of U.S. Smart TV Automatic Content Recognition , Northeastern University researchers (project website)
- Vizio, Samsung smart TVs seem to ignore tracking opt outs , Malwarebytes (2026-11-05)
- Samsung TVs stop spying on viewers in Texas. Here's how to disable ACR anywhere , Malwarebytes
- Vizio smart TVs are ignoring tracking opt-outs, continue to send data even when sitting idle , TechSpot
- Smart TV privacy study finds tracking persists even when opting out , CyberInsider
- Samsung and Vizio Smart TVs Still Send Tracking-Like Traffic After Users Turn It Off , Cybersecuritynews
- Study Claims Vizio Simply Ignores 'Smart' TV Spying Opt Out Requests , Slashdot (summarizing Techdirt) (2026-11-02)
- Desactivar el rastreo no basta: televisores de Samsung, Roku y Vizio siguen enviando datos de usuarios , Infobae (2026-11-11)
- LG slapped with lawsuit for spying on smart TV users as Samsung is called out again , HDTVTest
- Researchers Turned Off Tracking on a Vizio TV. It Kept Sending Data Anyway. , Yahoo Tech
- VIZIO, INC. and VIZIO Inscape Services, LLC (timeline item) - February 6, 2017 , Federal Trade Commission (2017-02-06)
- Vizio Settles Charges on Smart TV Surveillance , Courthouse News (2017-02-06)
- Federal Trade Commission v. Vizio , Deceptive.design
- Texas sues 5 smart TV manufacturers over data collection practices , The Record (Recorded Future News)
- How to Turn Off Smart TV Snooping Features , Consumer Reports (via Yahoo)
- Your smart TV is watching you watching TV, Consumer Reports finds , NBC News
- How to Disable ACR Tracking on Your Smart TV (2026) , smarttvs.org
- Smart TV ACR Tracking Study Finds Failed Opt-Outs and 57 Million Exposed Viewing Records , SecurityOnline