Indie games and AI: Big Walk shows how rulebooks split on code and art
A bug fix in a hit game has exposed how Steam, itch.io and indie awards each draw the line differently, and how little players can verify.
House House says it used chatbots on a slowdown bug in Big Walk and nowhere else. The case shows that platforms, awards bodies and players disagree on whether AI-assisted code counts, and that labels mostly rest on what developers say about themselves.
Whether an indie game can use AI and stay in good standing depends on which rulebook applies. According to trade reports, Steam asks for disclosure only of AI content that reaches players. itch.io's disclosure form lists code as a category. The Indie Game Awards and a group of 19 jurors at the Independent Games Festival (IGF) reject generative AI outright.
The gap became a public argument this month, when House House, the Melbourne studio behind Untitled Goose Game, confirmed that large language models (LLMs) helped with a bug in its new game, Big Walk. The studio says the final fix was about 10 lines of code that its own staff rewrote, and that it used no generative AI for art, audio, writing or voice. Those details come from the developer, relayed by news outlets, and nobody has independently audited them.
What Big Walk's developer says it did
House House confirmed to the outlet Aftermath that it used LLMs during development, then published a fuller disclosure in the game's FAQ on November 10, 2026, according to ScreenHub. As Video Games Chronicle reports it, the studio says the tools were used "sparingly" in the final stretch, to work through hard technical problems and bugs.
The main example, per Video Games Chronicle, involved third-party code. Studio staff and a Unity engineer could not fix a slowdown, so the team turned to a chatbot. Dexerto reports that the bug made the game run about 50% slower for roughly 20 seconds in sunrise and sunset scenes, and that House House modified the chatbot's suggestion extensively.
The studio puts the final fix at about 10 lines and estimates that "well under 0.1%" of the code was involved, as ScreenHub relays. That figure is a self-estimate. Only a code audit or version-control history could confirm it. Inven Global, relaying the developer, adds that no generative AI touched illustrations, music, writing or voice acting.
The studio also told Video Games Chronicle that it had no internal AI policy during development and considers that a failure. It apologized that its use may fall short of the standards of people trying to limit AI harms. That framing matters because the dispute is less about what the studio did than about which standard should apply to it.
How the disclosure surfaced
According to Video Games Chronicle, House House had mentioned the AI use in its IGF submission. Social-media claims then tied Big Walk to a statement from 19 IGF jurors. GameDev.net, summarizing Ars Technica, gives the jurors' stance as "declining to vote for any game that uses generative AI in any capacity." One report says the IGF's rules make no distinction between types of AI use, though that report appears to rewrite Ars Technica, which was not reviewed directly.
Dexerto describes Steam reviews as having been bombed after the disclosure, though no review counts or scores were found. As of Dexerto's report, no official announcement had confirmed that Big Walk was disqualified from the festival. Inven Global says the game launched in August, holds a Metacritic score of 91 and sold more than 1 million copies in its first week, but that is a single unverified source.
Where storefronts draw the line
Steam: what ships to players
Valve introduced its AI disclosure policy in January 2024 and rewrote the developer form in January 2026. The exact day is reported as January 16 by IndieForGames and January 17 by PapoGames. According to Tweaktown, the rewrite exempts AI-powered tools used for efficiency, such as code helpers, because their output is not player-facing.
Disclosure is still required for generative AI used for game content, store-page marketing material, and in-game images, audio and text, Tweaktown reports. TBreak adds that disclosures appear on the store page and that players can report illegal AI content. The policy asks for disclosure rather than banning AI, per Tech-Insider. PixelTwelve says Valve's question covers AI-assisted content that ships and is consumed by players, plus live-generated content.
One caution applies. Valve's own policy page was not reviewed for this article, so the Steam description rests on secondary coverage that is largely consistent. Big Walk's store page carries no AI label, which fits the exemption. One low-reliability aggregator, Tech-Insider, claims a June 2026 update requires AI tags for every asset type including code, but nothing else corroborates that, and it is not treated as established.
itch.io: code is on the form
According to its developer announcement, itch.io added a "Generative AI disclosure" field on November 20, 2024. A "yes" earns an "AI Generated" tag, and the creator must say whether the AI content is graphics, sound, text and dialog, or code. A "no" earns a "No AI" tag. That makes code a listed category on itch.io, unlike on Steam.
The platform's quality guidelines say traditional game AI such as pathfinding, enemy behavior and procedural generation is not generative AI and needs no disclosure. They also say itch.io is "strictly enforcing disclosure" for game asset, soundtrack, physical game, comic and book pages, with delisting possible for failing to tag. Games themselves are not in that list. The platform's stated reason for strictness is legal ambiguity around rights in generative AI content.
| Venue | AI-assisted code | AI-generated art, audio, text | Basis for the description |
|---|---|---|---|
| Steam | No disclosure needed since January 2026 | Disclosure required | Secondary reports; Valve's page not reviewed |
| itch.io | Code is a listed disclosure category | Disclosure requested or required, depending on project type | itch.io's own pages |
| Indie Game Awards | Policy says games using generative AI are strictly ineligible | Same | Comics Beat quoting the awards' policy |
| IGF jurors (19) | Won't vote for any game using generative AI | Same | Secondary reports of a statement of voting intent |
What awards bodies enforce, and why honesty counts
The closest precedent is Clair Obscur: Expedition 33. The Indie Game Awards gave it Debut Game and Game of the Year at a December 18, 2025 ceremony, then rescinded both two days later, according to the AV Club. The policy text quoted by Comics Beat reads: "Games developed using generative AI are strictly ineligible for nomination."
GamesRadar, quoting the awards' FAQ, says a Sandfall representative had agreed at submission that no generative AI was used. The studio then confirmed generative-AI art in production on the day of the ceremony. Tribune reports that the AI-generated textures shipped at launch and were patched out within days, and that the awards body considered their presence at launch enough to disqualify the game. Malay Mail specifies a patch five days later.
Sandfall said, per the AV Club, that the placeholder shipped accidentally and came from "brief" experimentation in 2022. The AV Club also notes the studio had told Spanish newspaper El País in July that it used "some, not much" generative AI. Malay Mail reports that players noticed the suspect textures soon after release, but the issue did not spread widely at the time.
The two cases differ in kind. In Clair Obscur, AI-made textures reached players, and an earlier assurance proved incomplete. In Big Walk, by the developer's account, the AI contributed to a bug fix that players never see, and the studio volunteered the information when it submitted to the festival. Awards bodies appear to be enforcing on honesty about disclosure as much as on the amount of AI used, though that reading is an interpretation based on a small number of cases.
The jurors' reasoning
According to PixelTwelve, the jurors argue that programming is creative work and that how the models were trained should count in an award decision. Both points apply whether or not the output is visible to players. Steam's logic points the other way: output the player never sees does not change the product they buy. The disagreement is partly about the facts of Big Walk, but mostly about whether the line should sit at shipped output, at process, or at the ethics of training data.
What game developers themselves think
The Game Developers Conference's November 2026 State of the Game Industry report found that 40% of surveyed professionals use generative AI tools for their job, up from 36% in the January 2026 edition. In the November survey, 55% say generative AI has a negative effect on the industry, 35% say mixed and 8% say positive. Among adopters, 57% use it daily. Game Developer puts the sample at more than 2,600 respondents.
The survey also shows where tolerance ends. According to GDC, many respondents see value in repetitive tasks, research, brainstorming and early prototyping, while opposition stays large for creative or player-facing uses. Respondents also flagged environmental impact, legal issues, job losses and skill atrophy. Those are the kinds of concerns that do not depend on whether AI output is visible in the finished game.
Opinion has also moved toward the negative. A January 2026 press release on BusinessWire reported 52% seeing a negative impact, up from 30% a year earlier and 18% the year before, with about 7% positive, down from 13%. The November report gives the prior figure as 54%, with a footnote that was not seen, so "52% to 55%" should not be read as a clean trend. The yearly samples also differ and are not strictly comparable.
Can players tell what a game used?
Largely, no. Code use is invisible by design, and the store labels on Steam and itch.io are self-declared. Gaming.net reports that itch.io's "No AI" label depends on what creators state, not on the platform verifying each project. Engadget notes that the platform does not state penalties for failing to tag games where tagging is warranted.
On November 3, 2026, itch.io added a "No AI" browse filter. According to Engadget, applying it cut the visible game count from more than 1.77 million to under 425,000. By Jaroha's arithmetic, that means roughly 24% or less of listings carry a "No AI" declaration. The other roughly 76% are a mixed group: some may be AI-free, some may have left the question unanswered, and some may have disclosed AI use.
The only case found in which players caught AI use themselves was Clair Obscur's textures, a visible artifact in shipped art. Even then, Malay Mail says the issue did not spread widely until later. No research on the reliability of detection methods for AI art or code was gathered, so no claim can be made about how well players or tools could spot AI use without a developer's disclosure.
Ownership: what US law says so far
The US Copyright Office's report Copyright and Artificial Intelligence, Part 2, released January 29, 2025, says using AI to assist creation, or including AI material in a larger human-authored work, does not by itself bar copyright, according to the Office's NewsNet. The same report says AI outputs are protectable only where a human determined sufficient expressive elements. That can mean perceptible human-authored work, or creative arrangement or modification of the output, but not the mere provision of prompts.
For developers, the practical reading is that AI-assisted work is not automatically uncopyrightable, while purely AI-generated material and prompt-only direction are not protected. How much human editing of AI-generated code is enough remains unresolved. A law-firm blog says it is unclear how much modification code needs, but that commentary is secondary and is not authoritative. The Copyright Office's Part 3, on training, was posted as a pre-publication version and was not reviewed here.
A line without a shared map
The Big Walk episode suggests that "is it OK" has no single answer yet. A game can be fully compliant on Steam, tagged accurately under itch.io's form, and still be unwelcome at an awards ceremony whose jurors reject any generative AI. The studio's own conclusion, that it should have had a policy before it started, may be the most transferable lesson.
What to watch is whether storefronts, juries and developers converge on a shared vocabulary, for example: no AI, AI in tools only, AI-generated assets, or live generation. Until then, disclosure rests on trust, and the amount of trust a label deserves depends on who is making the claim and whether anyone can check it.
Frequently asked questions
Does Steam require developers to disclose AI-assisted code?
According to trade reports on Valve's January 2026 form rewrite, no. AI-powered tools used for efficiency, such as code helpers, are exempt because their output is not player-facing. Disclosure is required for generative AI used in game content, store-page marketing and in-game images, audio and text. Valve's own page was not reviewed, so this rests on secondary coverage.
What exactly did Big Walk's developer use AI for?
House House says it used chatbots sparingly in the final stretch to research bugs, mainly in third-party code. The main example was a slowdown affecting sunrise and sunset scenes, which it turned into about 10 lines of rewritten code. The studio says it used no generative AI for art, audio, writing or voice. These are the developer's own statements and have not been independently verified.
How can players find out if an indie game uses AI?
Steam shows developer disclosures on the store page, and itch.io offers "AI Generated" and "No AI" tags plus a "No AI" browse filter added November 3, 2026. Both depend on what developers declare, and code use is invisible to players. No evidence was gathered on how reliably AI use can be detected independently.
Can a game made with AI-assisted code be copyrighted in the US?
The US Copyright Office's January 2025 report says AI assistance does not by itself bar copyright, and that AI material can sit inside a larger human-authored work. Outputs are protectable only where a human determined sufficient expressive elements, and prompts alone do not qualify. How much human editing of AI-generated code is enough remains unresolved.
Do most game developers support generative AI?
Not in the GDC's November 2026 survey of more than 2,600 professionals: 55% said generative AI has a negative effect on the industry, 35% said mixed and 8% said positive. Meanwhile, 40% use such tools for work. The sample skews Western and covers the industry broadly, not indie developers specifically.
Sources (30)
- Big Walk studio says it used AI 'sparingly' in response to indie award jury statement against its use , Video Games Chronicle (2026-11-01)
- Big Walk and generative AI: what we know so far about the House House controversy , ScreenHub
- Big Walk review bombed after House House admits AI touched "well under 0.1%" of code , Dexerto
- How 10 Lines of AI Debugging Code Led to an Indie Game Awards Boycott , Inven Global
- Big Walk's AI Bug Fixes and the IGF Awards Debate , PixelTwelve
- Big Walk used AI to fix a bug. Now the indie gaming world is having a reckoning. , GameDev.net
- Big Walk used AI to fix a bug. Now the indie gaming world is having a reckoning. , The Bold News
- Valve changes AI disclosure guidelines, 'AI powered tools' are now exempt , Tweaktown
- Steam updates AI disclosure policy: What developers need to report , TBreak
- Steam AI Disclosure Rules 2026: What You Must Declare , IndieForGames
- Steam AI Disclosure Rules 2026 — What Changed, Explained , PapoGames
- Tim Sweeney: Steam AI Disclosure Labels, 0 Sales Data [2026] , Tech-Insider
- Steam AI Disclosure Hits 36% of Games as Rivals Skip [2026] , Tech-Insider
- Generative AI Disclosure tagging - Developer Updates , itch.io (2024-11-20)
- Content creator quality guidelines , itch.io
- Itch.io adds a filter for games with gen AI disclosures , Engadget (2026-11-03)
- Itch.io Expands AI Disclosure Filters to Search Results , Gaming.net
- Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 loses Indie Game Awards due to gen AI , AV Club (2025-12-20)
- Clair Obscur: Expedition 33's controversial GOTY wins at The Indie Game Awards retracted after the RPG's use of generative AI , GamesRadar
- Indie Game Awards rescind CLAIR OBSCUR: EXPEDITION 33's wins for gen AI use , Comics Beat
- Indie Game Awards withdraw Clair Obscur honours over generative Ai asset use , Tribune
- Indie Game Awards rescinds honours from Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 for GenAI use , Malay Mail (2025-12-21)
- State of the Game Industry: November 2026 , GDC (2026-11-01)
- 2026 State of the Game Industry Report Reveals Widening Effect of Layoffs Broader Perspectives on Generative AI Unionization Tariffs and More , BusinessWire (2026-01-29)
- 2,600+ game devs weigh in on AI, layoffs, and next-gen consoles , Game Developer (2026-11-12)
- GDC's Survey Says Over 50% Of Game Devs See Gen AI As Harmful , 80.lv
- NewsNet Issue 1060 , U.S. Copyright Office (2025-01-29)
- Copyright Office Releases Part 2 of Artificial Intelligence Report , U.S. Copyright Office (2025-01-29)
- Copyright and Artificial Intelligence , U.S. Copyright Office
- AI Game Assets: Copyright, Platform Policy & IP (2025) , Promise Legal (2025-01-01)
This article was drafted with the help of AI and reviewed by Jaroha editors before publication.