Housing Is a Buyer's Market by One Measure and Balanced by Another
Pending sales are 16.4% below last year and monthly payments 11.1% higher, but national data do not point to one clear answer on waiting.
Redfin reports pending sales at the lowest level in its records, which begin in 2021, while the typical monthly payment is up 11.1% from a year ago. Sellers outnumber buyers by a record margin, yet months of supply and price cuts look closer to balanced. The evidence shows leverage for buyers in some places and thin demand everywhere, but it does not settle whether waiting pays.
By one prominent measure, the US housing market now favors buyers more than at any point in at least 13 years. Redfin estimated that sellers outnumbered buyers by 62.6% in September 2026, the widest gap in its data for that span. Yet the same company's months-of-supply figure sits in what it calls the balanced range, and national price indexes are still rising. Whether this is a buyer's market depends on which gauge is read, and where the house is.
The question is pressing because demand has dropped sharply. In the four weeks ending Nov. 1, 2026, seasonally adjusted pending sales were 275,484, down 16.4% from a year earlier and the lowest in Redfin's records, according to the company's Nov. 5 release. Over the same period, the median monthly mortgage payment was 11.1% higher than a year ago. Households weighing whether to buy or sell are facing weak activity and costly financing at once.
What the Redfin figures actually say
Pending sales count signed contracts that have not yet closed, so they act as an early read on demand. Redfin's four-week figure of 275,484 was down 0.6% from the previous week as well as 16.4% from a year ago. Pending sales also fell year over year in every major metro for the fourth consecutive week, according to a summary of the release in National Mortgage Professional.
The trend has built over several weeks. Figures that Redfin published in October, reproduced by Stock Titan, show the year-over-year decline widening from 14.4% to 15.9% to 16.4% across three consecutive four-week windows. The median monthly payment, by contrast, eased in dollar terms even as its gap with last year grew.
| Four weeks ending | Pending sales | Change from a year earlier | Median monthly payment | Payment change from a year earlier |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Oct. 18, 2026 | 281,749 | -14.4% | $2,796 | +10.4% |
| Oct. 25, 2026 | 276,352 | -15.9% | $2,786 | +10.7% |
| Nov. 1, 2026 | 275,484 | -16.4% | $2,777 | +11.1% |
Two cautions apply. Redfin appears to revise earlier weeks, so figures from separate reports do not always reconcile exactly. And the weekly series begins in 2021, so a record low means the lowest since then, not the lowest in any housing slump, including the one after 2008.
The comparison base also matters. A Freddie Mac release from November 2025, as carried by Barchart, described pending home sales at that time as the highest since the previous November. A 16.4% fall measured against a relatively strong year is steeper than the same level would look against a weak one.
Why the answer depends on the measure
The seller surplus is at a record
Redfin's monthly estimate of buyers and sellers is the source of the strongest buyer's-market claim. In September 2026 it counted about 929,000 buyers, the lowest on record and a fifth straight monthly decline, against about 1.51 million sellers, the most since March 2020. That produced the 62.6% surplus, and Redfin classed 41 of the 50 largest metros as buyer's markets, according to a secondary report of its release.
The surplus has climbed through the year. Redfin reported 44% in its January analysis and 51.3% for July, then 62.6% for September. Redfin also revises earlier months, so the latest published vintage is the one to trust, and the company uses its own methodology rather than a simple ratio of listings to closed sales.
Months of supply looks closer to balanced
Months of supply divides inventory by the sales pace, and it tells a more moderate story. Redfin's figure for the four weeks to Nov. 1 was 4.6 months, up from 4.0 a year earlier, and Redfin treats 4 to 5 months as balanced. The National Association of Realtors (NAR) reported 4.8 months for September, up from 4.5 a year before. A secondary source cites about 6 months as the benchmark some others use.
NAR's September inventory of 1.60 million homes was the highest since November 2019, according to Inman's coverage. Redfin's active-listing count was 1.50 million, up 2.1% from a year earlier. More homes are for sale than last year, but not by a wide enough margin to push months of supply past the balanced band.
Day-to-day leverage is modest
Indicators of negotiating power have moved only slightly, according to Redfin's four-week data to Nov. 1:
- Price cuts applied to 21.2% of listings, compared with 20.6% a year earlier.
- The typical home sat on the market 50 days, one day longer than a year earlier.
- The share of homes going off the market within two weeks slipped to 26.9% from 28%.
- The average sale-to-list price ratio was 98.3%, essentially unchanged from last year.
Those are real shifts, but small ones. Nationally, the leverage buyers hold looks more like a tilt than a reversal. Redfin economist Asad Khan, quoted by MortgagePoint, framed the market this way:
This is a buyer's market born out of caution, not strength.
Why payments are up 11.1% when prices are not
The 11.1% payment increase might suggest soaring home prices, but Redfin's median sale price was $388,604, down 0.4% from a year earlier. That was the third straight weekly year-over-year decline after three years of increases. The payment gap is therefore mostly a financing effect.
Redfin's payment figure of $2,777 was calculated at a 7.24% mortgage rate. Freddie Mac's survey put the 30-year fixed rate at 6.22% a year earlier, and a comparison of principal and interest on a 30-year loan at those two rates comes to roughly 11% more per month. That is Jaroha's own arithmetic rather than a Redfin calculation, but it is consistent with Redfin's number.
Rates have eased lately. Freddie Mac's survey showed 7.32% on Oct. 22, 7.24% on Oct. 29 and 7.18% on Nov. 5, three declines in a row. A mortgage-rate site and a realty-firm blog both report an October high of 7.40%, and the 15-year rate was 6.57% on Nov. 5. Even so, the 30-year rate remains about a percentage point above its level a year earlier.
The survey has a narrow scope. In a November 2025 release, Freddie Mac described it as focused on conventional, conforming, fully amortizing purchase loans for borrowers with 20% down and excellent credit. Buyers with smaller down payments or weaker credit may face different rates than the headline number.
Prices: flat in nominal terms, falling after inflation
National price measures disagree on direction, and the disagreement has a mundane cause. Redfin's median sale price covers a four-week window, NAR's median existing-home price covers a month, and both medians shift with the mix of homes that happen to sell. NAR itself cautions that changes in the composition of sales can distort median prices. The S&P Cotality Case-Shiller and FHFA indexes track repeat sales and so measure changes in value differently.
The readings differ accordingly: Redfin's median was down 0.4% year over year, NAR's median of $417,500 was up 1.3% for September (the 39th straight month of annual gains), the Case-Shiller national index was up 2.1% in August, and FHFA reported a 2.4% rise from August 2025 to August 2026. The periods and methods are not identical, so these numbers are not a like-for-like series. The defensible reading is that nominal prices are roughly flat to slightly higher nationally.
Adjusted for inflation, the picture is weaker. S&P's release put consumer-price inflation at 3.4% in August, about 1.3 percentage points above the Case-Shiller gain, which means home values fell in real terms for a 15th straight month. Cotality noted that not seasonally adjusted prices slipped 0.2% in August, against a usual pre-pandemic August gain of 0.3%, and cited seller lock-in and high rates as keeping sales near Great Recession lows.
Evidence that argues against calling this a price slide is also in the data. Cotality said annual price growth strengthened in August, and sellers are withdrawing: Redfin's new listings fell 4.6% year over year to their lowest level since January. A drop in listings limits how lopsided supply can become, which tends to support prices.
Location changes the answer
A national average hides wide gaps. The Case-Shiller release showed Chicago up 6.7% for the year to August and Seattle down 2.0%, a spread of nearly 9 percentage points. The same cities appear at opposite ends of other data: Seattle also had the steepest drop in pending sales in Redfin's latest weeks, at 30.5%.
Redfin's four-week data show the largest year-over-year pending-sales declines in Seattle (30.5%), San Diego (26.9%), Atlanta (26.3%), Denver (24.6%) and Las Vegas (22.6%). Redfin's August buyers-versus-sellers analysis found the strongest buyer's markets in the Sun Belt, with Nashville, Miami and Houston each having more than twice as many sellers as buyers. The company's report on September named Nassau County, New York, as the top seller's market, with 28.6% fewer sellers than buyers.
Not every local market is weakening. Redfin's Sept. 17 release noted that several Florida and other metros had rising pending sales in that period. The practical implication is that a national label reveals little about conditions on a particular street or in a particular price tier.
Why demand is falling, and what the data cannot say
Redfin and NAR both tie weak demand to high rates and costs, and Redfin adds caution. In its March 2026 analysis, a Redfin agent cited high property taxes, rising insurance costs and job-security fears. These are company and agent explanations, not tested causal estimates, and the sources do not separate how much of the drop comes from rates versus other pressures.
Closed sales show a milder decline than contracts. NAR reported that existing-home sales rose 1.5% in September from August but were 2.2% lower than a year earlier, at a seasonally adjusted annual rate of 3.99 million. NAR chief economist Lawrence Yun said August and September were the two slowest months for home sales this year, and described the market as scraping to the bottom of this home sales range.
Contracts usually precede closings by some weeks, so a 16.4% fall in pending sales could foreshadow weaker closings. That is an inference, not a finding in either source, and the two series differ in method, coverage and seasonal adjustment. NAR's October report, due in mid-November, will show whether the September uptick holds.
The sources also carry interests worth keeping in mind. Redfin is a brokerage owned by Rocket, a mortgage lender, and NAR is a trade association of real estate agents. Both benefit from market activity, and the figures here are their own, not independently audited.
Waiting versus acting: the tradeoffs the data show
The data describe conditions, not what any household should do. For buyers, the evidence shows more choice and some bargaining room than a year ago, set against a monthly payment about 11% higher. Redfin itself noted earlier this year that this is a buyer's market only for those who can afford to buy, a reminder that leverage means little to those priced out by financing costs.
Waiting has not been penalized so far this year in one narrow sense: the median payment has eased from $2,811 in early October to $2,777, and sale prices have slipped slightly. Whether that continues depends on interest rates and inflation, and the research gathered for this article includes no primary source on Federal Reserve policy or rate forecasts. A Redfin news-page headline hints at a possible December Fed hike, but the article itself was not available, so the outlook cannot be confirmed here.
For sellers, the data show thinner demand, more price cuts and, in some metros, falling prices. They also show that many sellers have already stepped back, which is why new listings are down. Real prices have declined for 15 months, a factor in any sell-or-hold calculation, though the sources do not quantify transaction costs, equity levels or how often sellers delist.
What to watch next
The current market is best described as one in which both sides have pulled back. Buyers are scarce because financing is expensive, sellers are leaving as offers thin out, and prices sit near a standstill. That is a different condition from the buyer's markets that follow price collapses, and it may be more fragile in either direction.
Three readings will do the most to clarify it: whether the three-week slide in mortgage rates continues below 7.18%, whether closed sales in NAR's October report begin to reflect the contract slump, and whether price declines in cities like Seattle spread to places that have so far held up, such as Chicago. Until then, the label depends on which measure and which metro are being read.
Frequently asked questions
Is it a buyer's market right now?
By Redfin's definition, yes: sellers outnumbered buyers by an estimated 62.6% in September, far above the 10% threshold. Other measures are less one-sided. Redfin's 4.6 months of supply falls in its balanced band, and national price indexes are still slightly positive. The Sun Belt shows much stronger buyer leverage than the Northeast and Midwest.
Why is the monthly payment up 11.1% if home prices are down?
The increase is driven mainly by the mortgage rate. Redfin's median payment was calculated at a 7.24% rate, while Freddie Mac recorded 6.22% a year earlier. The median sale price was down 0.4% from a year ago, so prices are not the cause.
Are home prices falling?
Not clearly at the national level. Redfin's median sale price was down 0.4%, but NAR's median was up 1.3%, Case-Shiller was up 2.1% and FHFA was up 2.4%, using different methods and periods. After inflation of 3.4%, Case-Shiller values have fallen for 15 straight months, and some metros such as Seattle are down in nominal terms.
What does a record-low pending sales figure mean?
Redfin's four-week pending sales of 275,484 are the lowest in its records, which begin in 2021. The figure is not a record against earlier housing downturns, and it is measured against a relatively strong year-earlier base. Weekly figures are also noisy and revised.
Should buyers wait for lower mortgage rates?
The research does not answer that, because it depends on individual finances and on a rate path the sources do not forecast. The data show rates falling for three straight weeks to 7.18%, but still about a point above a year earlier. A buyer's decision also turns on local conditions, which vary widely.
Sources (29)
- Homebuyers Get Some Relief as Prices Decline For Third Straight Week, Monthly Payments Dip , Redfin (2026-11-05)
- Redfin Reports Homebuyers Get Some Relief as Prices Decline for Third Straight Week, Monthly Payments Dip , PR Newswire (Redfin) (2026-11-05)
- Redfin: Homebuyers Gain Leverage, But Pending Sales Keep Sliding , National Mortgage Professional (2026-11-05)
- Redfin home prices fall 0.4% year over year , Stock Titan (Redfin release) (2026-11-05)
- Redfin Reports Homebuyers Get Some Relief as Prices Decline for Third Straight Week (press release) , Stockhouse (2026-11-05)
- Redfin: Pending Home Sales Fall 1.9%, Lowest Since 2021 , Stock Titan (Redfin release) (2026-10-22)
- Redfin: Home prices post first annual drop in over 3 years , Stock Titan (Redfin release) (2026-10-29)
- Price Declines, Easing Monthly Payments Offer Buyers Some Relief , The MortgagePoint (2026-11-05)
- Redfin Reports Pending Home Sales Dip to Lowest Level in Nearly 3 Years , Redfin (2026-09-17)
- Redfin Reports Home Sellers Now Outnumber Buyers By 63%, the Biggest Gap in at Least 13 Years , PR Newswire (Redfin) (2026-10-14)
- Redfin: In September, U.S. Sellers Outnumber Buyers by 62.6%, the Largest Gap Since 2013 , ABAB News (2026-10-14)
- Redfin: Home Sellers Outnumber Buyers by Record 63% , WRE News (2026-10-14)
- It's a Buyer's Market: America Has 44% More Home Sellers Than Buyers, a Near-Record Gap , Redfin (2026-02-01)
- The Number of U.S. Homebuyers Just Dropped to a Record Low, Shifting the Market Further in Buyers' Favor , Redfin
- It's Now The Strongest Buyer's Market on Record, Driven by the Sun Belt , Redfin
- Homebuyers Hold the Negotiating Power In 38 Major Metros, Up From 29 Last Year , Redfin
- Existing-Home Sales Increased 1.5% in September, According to NAR Report , National Association of Realtors (2026-10-13)
- Existing-Home Sales Increased 1.5% in September, According to NAR Report , GlobeNewswire (NAR) (2026-10-13)
- Existing-Home Sales September 2026: Pace Stays Under 4M, Rates Rise , Inman (2026-10-13)
- Existing Home Sales Treading Same Old Water , Mortgage News Daily (2026-10-16)
- Mortgage Rates - Freddie Mac , Freddie Mac (2026-11-05)
- A 15-year home loan averages 6.57%, Freddie Mac says; 30-year rates fell for a third straight week , Stock Titan (Freddie Mac release) (2026-11-05)
- Mortgage Rates Ease in Freddie Mac's Weekly Average , The Mortgage Reports (2026-11-04)
- Mortgage Rates Decline for Third Consecutive Week to 7.18% , Yahoo Finance (Freddie Mac) (2026-11-05)
- mortgage rates decrease , Barchart (Freddie Mac, Nov. 2025 release) (2025-11-20)
- S&P Cotality Case-Shiller Index Reports Annual Gain in August 2026 , S&P Dow Jones Indices (2026-10-27)
- S&P Cotality Case-Shiller Index Reports Annual Gain in August 2026 (release PDF) , S&P Dow Jones Indices (2026-10-27)
- August home price growth accelerates to 2.1% , Cotality (2026-10-27)
- Case-Shiller: National House Price Index Up 2.1% year-over-year in August , Calculated Risk (2026-10-27)